?

Log in

No account? Create an account
entries friends calendar profile Madamhydra's Lair Previous Previous Next Next
Convolutions of an Evil Mind
madamhydra
madamhydra
Feral-verse - Contagion 4/? (FF7 AU) (very VERY rough draft)
56 hisses or Hiss in my ear....
Comments
madamhydra From: madamhydra Date: September 19th, 2007 06:38 pm (UTC) (Link)
[ continued from above ]

I think I mentioned something about her difficulty in connecting intellectual knowledge to emotional awareness later on, and I guess it would apply to this as well. But if she just assumes that none of her friends would be into stuff like that then she's likely to avoid thinking about the question, the way she avoids thinking about the physical differences between her and Cloud, wouldn't she?

Yes, Tifa tends to avoid issues that bother her -- that much is clear from the original game, in which she avoids dealing with all the inconsistencies in Cloud's story (i.e., questioning Cloud) for as long as possible. While that's a fairly normal reaction to unpleasant things, the real problem lies in the way she avoids these sorts of issues in order to protect her dreams/fantasies and her particular view of the world. So with respect to situations that matter emotionally to her, she becomes rather self-absorbed and less sensitive to others' needs. In comparison, if she isn't emotionally involved, I can see Tifa as being fairly observant.

While Tifa's avoidance behavior wouldn't really cause problems in casual relationship with ordinary people, one can see how it can cause difficulties in building and maintaining more intimate relationships, even with normal men.

And that sort of behavior is a real relationship-killer when dealing with someone as complicated and psychologically damaged as Cloud. Cloud desperately needs someone who can understand him and read him, especially when so much of the time, Cloud barely understands or knows himself.

That's why I've always thought that in any relationship between Cloud and Sephiroth, or Cloud and Tifa, there really needs to be a third person (e.g., Zack and/or Aeris) who can translate and interprete 'Cloud' for the other partner. Both Sephiroth and Tifa (for very different reasons) just seem to lack a natural, intuitive gift in reading other people and their emotions.

Sort of like the way Cloud subconsciously classifies sane!Sephiroth as 'the General', someone far above him at the time, without normal human weaknesses?

Not really. Cloud's idealization has a decidedly vertical sort of dynamic -- i.e., a superior person (Sephiroth) and an inferior person (Cloud). Without Zack's interference, Cloud never would've presumed to bridge that gap and believe that Sephiroth could be interested in a nobody like him.

On the other hand, Tifa's idealization has a much more horizontal dynamic -- i.e., the brave handsome hero (Cloud) and his brave, beautiful lady (Tifa). In other words, Tifa doesn't really look up to Cloud as much as she looks toward. He's idealized, but also attainable.

Does that make sense? ^_^;
jessara40k From: jessara40k Date: September 20th, 2007 01:04 pm (UTC) (Link)
Of course Zack's relationship with Cloud is actually the culmination of a lot of blood, sweat and tears -- literally, considering all the work, care, patience, and sacrifices Zack made -- but it probably looks effortless to Tifa.

Especially since Cloud isn't likely to have said much to Tifa about how they got together.

That's an important decision point because it will be the first time in the story that all four of them are together (at least in spirit) and able to talk to each other.

Might be a bit of a hint for Cloud about how he was involved with Sephiroth, but he'd probably refuse to recognise it.

I don't want the story to get too drawn out, but the more I think about it, it really does make sense Zack and Aeris to NOT tell Cloud for a little longer at least, especially now Zack realizes the extent of Cloud's inability to identify Sephiroth as being one of his lovers. While the sight/scent/touch of Zack was enough to trigger Cloud's suppressed memories about Zack and Aeris, it clearly isn't enough to overcome Cloud's current case of 'hysterical blindness' with respect to Sephiroth.

So, they're more likely to give Cloud a bit more time to get past his 'blindness' by himself, the way Sephiroth wants them to, but they still fully intend to tell him before Sephiroth is brought back?

And that sort of behavior is a real relationship-killer when dealing with someone as complicated and psychologically damaged as Cloud. Cloud desperately needs someone who can understand him and read him, especially when so much of the time, Cloud barely understands or knows himself.

Yeah, I bet.

That's why I've always thought that in any relationship between Cloud and Sephiroth, or Cloud and Tifa, there really needs to be a third person (e.g., Zack and/or Aeris) who can translate and interprete 'Cloud' for the other partner. Both Sephiroth and Tifa (for very different reasons) just seem to lack a natural, intuitive gift in reading other people and their emotions.

I've only had Cloud and Sephiroth's relationship fall apart because of that once in my own fic, in my Chosen universe, and I think that pre-Nibelheim it might work. It would probably be sort of co-dependent, or very much based on the physical, but Cloud isn't quite that badly damaged before Nibelheim, and his main problem then is lack of confidence IMO.

Not really. Cloud's idealization has a decidedly vertical sort of dynamic -- i.e., a superior person (Sephiroth) and an inferior person (Cloud). Without Zack's interference, Cloud never would've presumed to bridge that gap and believe that Sephiroth could be interested in a nobody like him.

On the other hand, Tifa's idealization has a much more horizontal dynamic -- i.e., the brave handsome hero (Cloud) and his brave, beautiful lady (Tifa). In other words, Tifa doesn't really look
up to Cloud as much as she looks toward. He's idealized, but also attainable.

Does that make sense? ^_^;


Yes, it makes sense. But both apporaches are equally far from reality.
madamhydra From: madamhydra Date: September 20th, 2007 11:34 pm (UTC) (Link)
Especially since Cloud isn't likely to have said much to Tifa about how they got together.

If he mentions anything about Zack to her (other than what the original game revealed) Cloud would probably do in the briefest and most superficial way, simply becaue of the painful emotional associations.

Might be a bit of a hint for Cloud about how he was involved with Sephiroth, but he'd probably refuse to recognise it.

Oh, there'll be hints. Not too obvious, but not terribly subtle, either.

So, they're more likely to give Cloud a bit more time to get past his 'blindness' by himself, the way Sephiroth wants them to, but they still fully intend to tell him before Sephiroth is brought back?

They will definitely want to give Cloud more time. Once he remembered about Zack and Aeris, it's inevitable that he'd remember about Sephiroth... eventually.

As for telling him, Zack and Aeris will probably end up being forced to tell him AFTER Sephiroth returns. Why? Because Sephiroth gets brought back prematurely by a human faction for their own selfish reasons.

I've only had Cloud and Sephiroth's relationship fall apart because of that once in my own fic, in my Chosen universe, and I think that pre-Nibelheim it might work. It would probably be sort of co-dependent, or very much based on the physical, but Cloud isn't quite that badly damaged before Nibelheim, and his main problem then is lack of confidence IMO.

A strictly Sephiroth-Cloud relationship (without significant sexual or non-sexual involvement from Zack) might be feasible pre-Nibelheim, but IMO, it would still be a rather tenuous and dysfunctional relationship. Neither of them are very good at communicating their emotional needs. So call me unimaginative, but I end up picturing bouts of hot sex, tense insecure silences, and not much else.
jessara40k From: jessara40k Date: September 21st, 2007 08:46 am (UTC) (Link)
They will definitely want to give Cloud more time. Once he remembered about Zack and Aeris, it's inevitable that he'd remember about Sephiroth... eventually.

Makes sense. And it's probably better for his mental health if he remembers it by himself.

As for telling him, Zack and Aeris will probably end up being forced to tell him AFTER Sephiroth returns. Why? Because Sephiroth gets brought back prematurely by a human faction for their own selfish reasons.

And that's not going to help the humans' case at all, is it?

A strictly Sephiroth-Cloud relationship (without significant sexual or non-sexual involvement from Zack) might be feasible pre-Nibelheim, but IMO, it would still be a rather tenuous and dysfunctional relationship. Neither of them are very good at communicating their emotional needs. So call me unimaginative, but I end up picturing bouts of hot sex, tense insecure silences, and not much else.

Hmmm. Guess it depends on the set up. Zack is involved in my Keeper-verse, but even if he wasn't I've given them a telepathic/empathic link to compensate for their reluctance to speak to each other. With Responsive I had a required teacher-student relationship beforehand, and Sephiroth has a strong enough sense of duty to make that work by force of will. In Chosen, pre-Nibelheim, you've just about nailed what sort of relationship Sephiroth and Cloud had, and in my Handler continuity Zack's still their friend, a fairly close friend.
56 hisses or Hiss in my ear....